Article Text

Download PDFPDF
2SPD-003 Magnetic double pigtail stent: an economically interesting innovative device?
  1. R Pieragostini1,
  2. E Cauchetier1,
  3. H Oro2,
  4. O Chauvel1,
  5. P Certain3,
  6. C Tardy1,
  7. I Merouani1,
  8. JL Pons1
  1. 1Centre Hospitalier d’Argenteuil, Pharmacie à Usage Intérieur, Argenteuil, France
  2. 2Centre Hospitalier d’Argenteuil, Service de Chirurgie Urologique, Argenteuil, France
  3. 3Centre Hospitalier d’Argenteuil, Endoscopie, Argenteuil, France


Background Standard Double Pigtail Stents (DPS) are commonly sterilisable medical devices (SMD). Their removal includes a flexible endoscope for male patients and a cystoscope for female ones. They are therefore removed by the surgeon and nurse. As this procedure may be painful for patients and often not easy to use, the Magnetic Black Star Kit (MBSK) was developed. It is composed of a DPS fitted with a magnet, a guide wire and a magnetic recovery system. This new device highlights a faster removal by a nurse only.

Purpose The aim of the study is to evaluate the cost of standard DPS and their removal in order to determine if MBSK could be economically viable.

Material and methods For standard ablations, the average cost of staff is calculated according to the time spent on the procedure taking into account the surgeon’s and the nurse’s wages. Costs credited to SMD are determined by purchase or depreciation prices, disinfection, sterilisation and repairing costs. Then, costs of each single used medical devices (SUMD) required for the procedure are collected. Total costs for males and females are compared to costs associated with MBSK (including kit price and cost of its DPS removal procedure). Identical costs for both methods have not been considered.

Results For the ablation of DPS in males, the average cost of staff is €20 depending on procedure times. The cost of SMD rises to €85 due to the outsourcing of the sterilisation unit and the disinfection of the endoscope. SUMD cost €69. The total cost of a DPS and its classical removal in males is therefore €174. In females, the total cost is €137, with €12 for staff costs, €56 to the SMD and €69 to the SUMD. On the other side, the total cost of MBSK is €115, with €112 for the kit price and €3 for the procedure, according to feedback. All things considered, reductions in the cost reach 35% for males and 15% for females compared to the classical method.

Conclusion Using MBSK will be economically viable at the hospital and will avoid the use of fragile devices such as endoscopes.

No conflict of interest

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.